Yes, the iOS 4 (formerly known as the iPhone OS 4) landed on the iPhone and iPod Touch today. Although many (hate to admit, but me included) were initially enthralled when Steve Jobs showcased it two months ago. Now that it's here, does it take back the excitement that I've shared with Android phones all this while? While I will still agree that Apple's certain UI features, like the copy-paste magnifying-glass system is still unbeatable. But in a few ways, I feel Android is still better than the iOS 4. Forget phone specifications, what I'm referring to here is purely the usability of the two systems. Here are five things that I dig about Android over the iOS.
1) Notifications
This was a big, big bummer with the iOS 4. Android has one of the best mode of notifications one could ever want right since its day of inception. And its surprising to see Apple have NO improvements for this highly-criticized system. For those who haven't used either phones, let me explain how is Android's is better.
In Android, All notifications (like a new SMS, reply to a chat conversation, new e-mail etc.) are neatly organized in an expandable menu. So, whenever any of these notifications come to life, they are simply displayed for some time in a small strip that always stays atop the screen. So, consider that you're chatting with a friend on Gtalk, while surfing the web. Whenever the person replies, you'll see it in that small strip, without it disrupting whatever activity you're doing. To respond back, you'll need to just swipe that strip down to open the proper notifications menu.

While the iOS 4 still follows the old method of pop-up notifications that will keep disturbing you. So, every reply to your chat conversation or a new SMS will make the iPhone bring a pop-up menu in focus, requiring you to take an action before you can get back to what you were doing. This is not good, especially now that they've got multi-tasking working, they could have done better with handling notifications. Not to mention the fact that the pop-up reveals content right in your face, for any prying eye to easily get a glimpse of.

2) Lack of physical menu keys
Apple's philosophy to keep things simple and clean resulted in the iPhone having just one big button on the phone. This button primarily takes you to the home-screen, is now is also used for switching between apps. In my experience of shuffling between iOS and Android-based devices, I actually began to like the extra physical buttons on the Android. For instance, the dedicated back button on Android phones is much easier than the soft-key on the iPhone. For one, I found the its fixed bottom-placement on Android phones to be easier to hit than having to stretch my thumb all the way to the top-right corner in the iPhone. Same goes for the dedicated menu key. The Search button to me is probably the least useful of all four.

3) Widgets
Widgets have been around on not just smart-phones, but even on closed OSes like Samsung's TouchWiz. They're little elements that can lie on your home-screen, providing you with little pieces of useful information. Or even the ability to quickly change a setting. With the iPhone, its all about opening and closing apps, even if you have to check simple things like the Weather, stocks, twitter updates etc. They solved the problem of app-icon clutter by introducing folders, a really good step I believe. But if you're going to arrange apps in folders, then consider that one more click before you can see what you want, instead of having it placed directly on the home-screen.
Android makes good use of Widgets. I like how I am able to put a widget for the week's Weather, Twitter/Facebook feeds, music player controls, among many others. With multiple home-screens, I can arrange an assortment of Widgets that I can swipe across swiftly. Heck, the widget to toggle Wi-fi, Bluetooth, display brightness and GPS is much better than going to the Settings menu on iOS, followed by hitting individual menus to turn them on or off.
4) A simple way to transfer media 
A classical issue that we've been harping over and over since we used the iPods. The dependency to use only iTunes to transfer your media is simply not acceptable to me. I am an old-school guy. I like to copy-paste my music onto a phone the good ol' way -- via Windows Explorer (or any other File management system). It is irritating for me to have iTunes add music to its library first, then having to 'sync' it to the iPhone.

Speaking of file transfers -- the iOS 4 still doesn't allow transferring files over Bluetooth. Now one may argue that you can always e-mail that file and ask the other person to download it from the other end. But when there exists a technology that lets you transmit data wirelessly between devices; a technology that exists even in the cheapest of phones today, it feels bad that the iPhone still can't do the same. Thank god Android 2.1 and above supports this out of the box.
5) The LED notification light
The small LED notification light is a boon when you leave your phone on a desk for a long time. The iPhone screen will shut down after momentarily displaying a new notification. You wouldn't know any new activity without turning it on to check manually. But the LED light on Android phones keep blinking, letting you know something new has occurred for you to see. Acer has gone one step further in their iteration of LED notification for their Liquid phone.

So, what am I trying to prove here? I'm just trying to put some clarity into people who are led to believe that "iOS 4 is the best ever!". There's no doubt that Apple brought in a revolution in touch-based user interfaces to which Google and all other makers should be thankful. Because it is only on the basis of some of these key design philosophies have others been able to come up with their own iteration of a 'finger-friendly' OS. Before Android, there was no doubt that Apple's iPhone OS was at a high pedestal nobody could reach. Today, things are different. Be warned, Apple.
Do you agree with this article?
