• 5 areas where Android still beats iOS 4

    5 areas where Android still beats iOS 4

    Rohan Naravane, Jun 22, 2010 2121 hrs IST

    iOS 4? Meh. I still dig Android in some ways

    mail share

Yes, the iOS 4 (formerly known as the iPhone OS 4) landed on the iPhone and iPod Touch today. Although many (hate to admit, but me included) were initially enthralled when Steve Jobs showcased it two months ago. Now that it's here, does it take back the excitement that I've shared with Android phones all this while? While I will still agree that Apple's certain UI features, like the copy-paste magnifying-glass system is still unbeatable. But in a few ways, I feel Android is still better than the iOS 4. Forget phone specifications, what I'm referring to here is purely the usability of the two systems. Here are five things that I dig about Android over the iOS. 

1) Notifications

This was a big, big bummer with the iOS 4. Android has one of the best mode of notifications one could ever want right since its day of inception. And its surprising to see Apple have NO improvements for this highly-criticized system. For those who haven't used either phones, let me explain how is Android's is better. 

In Android, All notifications (like a new SMS, reply to a chat conversation, new e-mail etc.) are neatly organized in an expandable menu. So, whenever any of these notifications come to life, they are simply displayed for some time in a small strip that always stays atop the screen. So, consider that you're chatting with a friend on Gtalk, while surfing the web. Whenever the person replies, you'll see it in that small strip, without it disrupting whatever activity you're doing. To respond back, you'll need to just swipe that strip down to open the proper notifications menu. 

 


While the iOS 4 still follows the old method of pop-up notifications that will keep disturbing you. So, every reply to your chat conversation or a new SMS will make the iPhone bring a pop-up menu in focus, requiring you to take an action before you can get back to what you were doing. This is not good, especially now that they've got multi-tasking working, they could have done better with handling notifications. Not to mention the fact that the pop-up reveals content right in your face, for any prying eye to easily get a glimpse of. 


 



2) Lack of physical menu keys


Apple's philosophy to keep things simple and clean resulted in the iPhone having just one big button on the phone. This button primarily takes you to the home-screen, is now is also used for switching between apps. In my experience of shuffling between iOS and Android-based devices, I actually began to like the extra physical buttons on the Android. For instance, the dedicated back button on Android phones is much easier than the soft-key on the iPhone. For one, I found the its fixed bottom-placement on Android phones to be easier to hit than having to stretch my thumb all the way to the top-right corner in the iPhone. Same goes for the dedicated menu key. The Search button to me is probably the least useful of all four.


 


3) Widgets

Widgets have been around on not just smart-phones, but even on closed OSes like Samsung's TouchWiz. They're little elements that can lie on your home-screen, providing you with little pieces of useful information. Or even the ability to quickly change a setting. With the iPhone, its all about opening and closing apps, even if you have to check simple things like the Weather, stocks, twitter updates etc. They solved the problem of app-icon clutter by introducing folders, a really good step I believe. But if you're going to arrange apps in folders, then consider that one more click before you can see what you want, instead of having it placed directly on the home-screen.  

Android makes good use of Widgets. I like how I am able to put a widget for the week's Weather, Twitter/Facebook feeds, music player controls, among many others. With multiple home-screens, I can arrange an assortment of Widgets that I can swipe across swiftly. Heck, the widget to toggle Wi-fi, Bluetooth, display brightness and GPS is much better than going to the Settings menu on iOS, followed by hitting individual menus to turn them on or off. 



4) A simple way to transfer media 


 


A classical issue that we've been harping over and over since we used the iPods. The dependency to use only iTunes to transfer your media is simply not acceptable to me. I am an old-school guy. I like to copy-paste my music onto a phone the good ol' way -- via Windows Explorer (or any other File management system). It is irritating for me to have iTunes add music to its library first, then having to 'sync' it to the iPhone. 


 

Speaking of file transfers -- the iOS 4 still doesn't allow transferring files over Bluetooth. Now one may argue that you can always e-mail that file and ask the other person to download it from the other end. But when there exists a technology that lets you transmit data wirelessly between devices; a technology that exists even in the cheapest of phones today, it feels bad that the iPhone still can't do the same. Thank god Android 2.1 and above supports this out of the box. 

5) The LED notification light
 
The small LED notification light is a boon when you leave your phone on a desk for a long time. The iPhone screen will shut down after momentarily displaying a new notification. You wouldn't know any new activity without turning it on to check manually. But the LED light on Android phones keep blinking, letting you know something new has occurred for you to see. Acer has gone one step further in their iteration of LED notification for their Liquid phone.




So, what am I trying to prove here? I'm just trying to put some clarity into people who are led to believe that "iOS 4 is the best ever!". There's no doubt that Apple brought in a revolution in touch-based user interfaces to which Google and all other makers should be thankful. Because it is only on the basis of some of these key design philosophies have others been able to come up with their own iteration of a 'finger-friendly' OS. Before Android, there was no doubt that Apple's iPhone OS was at a high pedestal nobody could reach. Today, things are different. Be warned, Apple. 


 

Follow Techtree on Twitter

Do you agree with this article?
YesNo

Discuss this article
( All fields are mandatory )
Please Note: Comments that include links (URLs) will be caught by the spam filter and will not show up on the website until manually approved by the moderator.
Comment here
Name
City
E-mail
Word Verification
Type the characters you see in the picture below.
Enter the characters appearing in this image
           Refresh Captcha



Discussion Board
(26) Comments
raf
,syd, on Oct 08, 2011 09:23 AM
i like the popup notifications because i can just take my phone out and see the popup, how can i get this on android? i only have it for sms but i want it for all messenger apps i.e. nimbuzz.
Gil
,Hyderabad, on Jul 08, 2010 12:55 AM
Good article . Being the hardcore fan of jobs i went behind iphone. Rocking piece from apple inc every one will love this device, which changed the smart phone world. when it comes to "OS" jobs closed the door too much we need to listen what he says. jail-breaking can give some solution but not much. Its really a good gaming device and apps are too costly. On the other side google is shaping their android nicely, recently bought xperia x10 mini very good device packed with android OS 1.6. multitasking was gr8 without any sluggishness, notification bar real advantage, few apps are available but most of them are free, no more syncing with itunes, open source & open market there comes reall advantage . waiting for froyo update which makes the "OS" more faster with more features. " Every iphone user, if you start using android you will come to know, how our hands are tied with IOS "
Vatdoro
,Highland, on Jun 22, 2010 10:21 PM
Overall, it's a pretty good article. I LOVE my iPhone, so I'm obviously biased that way, but this was interesting. 1) Notifications - I do agree that the current iOS notification system needs some work, but I think it's a little complicated. I'm not sure how Android handles TONS of notifications, say an app sent you 50 notifications. How does Android handle that? You really don't want to see all of those notifications. 2) physical buttons - I think this one is very subjective. Personally I prefer the touchscreen to the buttons. 3) Widgets - Maybe it's just me, but I'm not a fan of widgets. My desktop/laptop computers have supported them for years, but I just turn them off now because I find them distracting. 4) It would be nice to use my iPhone as a flash drive. At the same time, the simplicity of iTunes synching is incredible. That's one thing no other phone has right now. A complete software solution to synch all your media with your devices (music, movies, tv shows, photos, books, etc). 5) LED notification light - I did not know some Android phones have this features. It is pretty cool. I would definitely find that feature useful on my iPhone.
Tarun
,Pune, on Jun 26, 2010 07:13 PM
you say 'all your media' as if they are tons of diff stuff.. had there been simple drag and drop support there is no need to classify stuff.. just copy paste whatever you want..
Sujal
,New Delhi, on Jul 02, 2010 05:07 PM
@tarun-Its subjective! Many people do have tons of media. Take my example, I have about 6-7 GB of music which I would like to carry all the time on my device and listen to the songs depending on my mood. Apart from this music, I have more music saved on my laptop which I rarely listen to so dont feel the need to carry them. Videos or movies, I have in exactly "tons". Whatever little moments, I like to capture them in pics or videos and keep them with me. I am a big movie buff so lots of movies too.
Sujal
,New Delhi, on Jun 26, 2010 03:21 PM
nice article. But I still believe iOS is still way ahead of Android. And quite liked the fact that you mentioned ignore the phone specs. Most of the time its iPhone vs Droid or Legend or Evo 4g. C'mon.. its like SRK vs Aamir Khan/Amitabh Bachan/Tom Cruise and blah. coming to the OS, i really love iOS. Believe me, its so damn easy to use. You touch the phone and your like "oh, this is familiar." iOS is more elegant too and even without customization, I feel it looks better than android. The best thing about iOS? JAILBREAK! :P
Matt
,Warrington, on Jun 22, 2010 09:53 PM
Great article. Some of these improvements are ones I would definitely like to see come to iOS. The notification system on the iPhone was designed for SMS and to have it expanded across all apps was a bit of a design flaw I believe. I think the iTunes syncing is much preferable to Androids drag and drop, the ability to have an organised library to simply just having files is much better. Of course, I suspect that this will soon move to the cloud, and that iTunes and iPhones will all sync to this, rather than iTunes being the main hub. Widgets I would love to see, but I believe that this would require a fundamental rethinking of the home screen. Folders are a welcome addition, but the home screen will need an overhaul. It'll last to iOS 5, but I think by 6 we'll see a rethinking.
RichInPA
,Philadelphia, on Jun 25, 2010 10:22 PM
You can sync with iTunes with a $3 app from the market. I am disorganized so I like that kind of organization too BUT it is nice to have the option to drag and drop like if I want to grab a podcast to listen to on the train from my work computer and just drag it over. What is more important to me is to have total control over the storage via an SD card. I can expand the memory as I want and I can drag and drop any kind of file on there. Widgets are very cool. I always see people comparing them to the Gadgets for Windows 7 or whatever they are called in OSX both of which are pretty much useless to me but they work great on a phone and would expect Apple to adopt them. I have always liked the iPhone hardware and I am glad we are starting to see some comparable handsets running Android. I don't see the UI tweaks the manufacturers make as a problem since it is simple to get root on most android devices and then you can either run the plain Android version or whichever theme you choose.
Mukul Sharma
,Delhi, on Jun 24, 2010 12:44 PM
you should see that even afteer having these negatives it still sells more than android. 1. iphone is very costly as compared to android phones, u can find one for Rs.12000/- 2. Android fones are made my more thn one comp. eg samsung, lg. etc etc. still iphone beats android phones. and your 2 nd last point were simply useless for me, havnt u used any phone which didnt give u notification lites? and 2ndly y do u need buttons at all in a touch screen phone.? thank you
pankaj
,new delhi, on Jun 24, 2010 12:18 AM
itunes is one of the most frustrating thing comes with ipod. you have to sync it with ipod. now if somehow u format ur pc and reinstall itunes, it say to sync device. then u lost all ur tracks on ipod. some of the function in iphone are very frustrating, like its bluetooth.
krizanand
,hyderabad, on Jun 23, 2010 11:07 PM
Nice article Techtree, really Apple fanbois have to read this and should realise Oh! are these things on phones? they believe everything Mr.Jobs says ex: Iphone has the best 5Mp camera and best ever display ever put on a phone LOL. Apple are really losing some basic things which a smartphone should possess, Bluetooth OBEX is a good example of it.
fatboy
,Toronto, on Jun 22, 2010 09:44 PM
excellent info
Jim
,Miami, on Jun 23, 2010 05:37 AM
iPhone 4 has notification lights on the rear panel. If the phone is facing up, you'll see the notification on the screen. If the phone is facing down, you'll see the notification light blinking.
Clarence
,Sterling, on Jun 23, 2010 12:17 AM
You Can Use the App Easy Phone Tunes for the Android to sync Your Itunes library to the phone.
stuey Sutfliff
,Liverpool, on Jun 22, 2010 11:52 PM
Being an iPhone user from the start (I am still using my first gen iPhone), I agree with most of your points, especially having a notification LED on the outside of the phone. Without this, Apple forces the user to have to power up the screen to see if there is a message. This is ridiculous and I am surprised this has STILL not been acknowledged or added. WTF, Apple?? I wonder if someone will make an app that will make the camera flash on the iPhone 4 light up when there is a message? As for syncing, Im not sure what the problem with using iTunes to manage your music. I find it tedious and time consuming to sync my phone with iTunes also, but I found that I can check the "Manually manage music" button and then just manually drag songs onto the phone without having to sync the entire phone. This even works when you drag directly from a file or your desktop.
Karthik
,Leeds, on Jun 22, 2010 11:28 PM
Nice article, very informative. @Sajjad, Just having physical buttons is useless if OS does not support interaction with them, so it IS a feature of OS too. it applies vice versa, if the hardware does not have those buttons, it cannot make use of such a facility. Android wins on this point. I am very much convinced that Usabilitywise, Android wins. The only area where Iphone wins is the hardware - the sensitivity if the screen to touch. however HTC has come very close from HTC Desire onwards. I hated the restrictions and lack of compatibility of Apple products - like they are not detected as a simple folder on windows. You need Itunes or any software to sync. Simply unacceptable. I would definitely choose android and a good hardware instead of Iphone and IOS.
Rohan
,TechTree, on Jun 22, 2010 11:44 PM
I absolutely agree with the part that the iPhone screen sensitivity is the best available, but HTC's Android phones are pretty usable too.
Sajjad Haideral
,London, ON, on Jun 22, 2010 10:17 PM
This article doesn't make much sense - we are talking about an operating system. So how does lack of physical button and LED notification light come in to affect? Those are physical features, based on difference handset manufacturers. As a recent software engineering graduate, I find it damn well annoying to see comparisons that are not software related at any level.
Rohan
,TechTree, on Jun 22, 2010 11:38 PM
As @Karthik correctly pointed out, although we may be talking about an operating system, the hardware buttons are in fact a function of what the software can support. Most of the Android phones shipped today come with the back/home/menu button, as well as the LED notification light. In my opinion, these improved the usability of the Android phones and thus I found it worth mentioning them
Kieran Hart
,Toronto, ON, on Jun 22, 2010 11:16 PM
Those each of these has their own unique perks, i still and always will be a BlackBerry fan. I still do not believe that these two have handled the security aspect like RIM has.
Rosco
,Perth, Scotland, on Jun 22, 2010 11:03 PM
Two words. Helicopter. View. Thank you
cloud
,vancouver, on Jun 22, 2010 10:40 PM
Please hire an editor. Sentence fragments. Avoid them.
Adrian
,Toronto Canada, on Jun 22, 2010 10:35 PM
Switched to Android (on Motorola Milestone) and have to say I would never go back... your article is absolutely correct... and the more you use Android the more you realize how much easier everyday things are done with the system. Apple, beware.
Jim
,Toronto, ON, on Jun 22, 2010 10:23 PM
Sajjad Haideral is correct. Not every android phone even has an notification light. The LG Eve doesn't have one at all.
Sebastian
,NYC, on Jun 22, 2010 09:51 PM
Who cares??
R. Millar
,Vancouver, on Jun 22, 2010 10:04 PM
17 people do. And I fel you do as well.If not, why did you read the article and leave a comment.If you truly didn't care, there would be no record of you ever being here.

Opinion Poll